ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) is a framework that companies use to assess their performance and business practices on various ethical and sustainability issues. Over the past few years, environmentally conscious individuals have pursued ESG careers to help companies achieve business sustainability and embrace social responsibility.
Even though more and more individuals are pursuing ESG careers, the ESG job market has been met with some criticism from employees, customers, and stakeholders. This post discusses everything you need to know about the ESG job market, including criticisms that have riddled the market.
Table of Contents
Criticisms of the ESG Job Market
1: That It Lacks Standardization
Some employees, customers, stakeholders, and investors argue that there is no universally accepted standard on how ESG criteria are defined and measured.
Rating agencies and small, medium-sized, and well-established companies may use different criteria, sourcing processes, or scoring methodologies, making it difficult to compare the ESG performance of different companies.
Moreover, the lack of standardization in the ESG job market can make it difficult for investors to invest ethically since ESG criteria do not provide the real picture.
2: Some Companies May Engage in Greenwashing
Critics argue that some companies in the ESG job market may engage in greenwashing, also known as green sheen, or present their operations as sustainable when they are nowhere near to being sustainable.
Greenwashing occurs when companies use misleading branding to appeal to eco-conscious customers. For example, some bottling companies claim that their bottles are ‘environmentally friendly’, but the lids contain harmful substances.
Some companies even go as far as presenting their products as ‘environmentally friendly’, not taking into account the greenhouse gasses dumped into the atmosphere during the production process.
Greenwashing deceives customers and investors into believing that a company is environmentally friendly, making it difficult for these individuals to evaluate the real sustainability of a company.
3: It Offers Low Profitability
Focusing on ESG criteria can cause a company to go into a downward financial spiral. Critics of the ESG job market argue that companies prioritizing social responsibility and sustainability may not be as profitable as those prioritizing traditional financial metrics.
4: It Prioritizes Reporting Over Real Action
ESG critics argue that ESG reporting does not bring about real change since many companies view ESG reporting as a “tick-the-box” exercise. As such, these companies focus all their attention on compiling ESG reports instead of implementing strategies that can improve their ESG performance.
5: It Makes Little to No Impact
Finally, critics of the ESG job market argue that ESG measures have very little impact on the environment and society. The lack of impact can be attributed to a lack of clear goals or a lack of accountability among companies.
Creating a Better Future for the ESG Job Market
The concerns discussed above are all valid. If you want to pursue an ESG career, you should be ready to address these concerns. Even though you cannot do this overnight, joining the ESG workforce is a step in the right direction to improve the current condition of the ESG job market. It will also help you on your way to leaving the world a better place than you found it.
